Telehealth payments

ACH and eCheck for Telehealth Memberships: Authorization Rules for Recurring Debits

Bank debits suit some telehealth memberships better than cards, but the authorization has to be right and returns come back on the bank's schedule, not yours. These are the rules that decide whether a recurring ACH program holds up.

By VyaPayPublished 7 min read

A recurring ACH or eCheck debit for a telehealth membership needs the patient's authorization in writing or by a similarly authenticated method, with a copy given to the patient, under Regulation E. Nacha adds account validation on the first debit from an account entered online, and return-rate thresholds that put a program under review. Get those right before you offer bank payment alongside cards.

eCheck is the industry name for an ACH debit from a checking or savings account that the account holder authorizes online or by phone, instead of writing a paper check. For an online-authorized consumer debit, Nacha's WEB entry rules apply, including account validation the first time an account number is used.

What Regulation E requires for recurring debits

Authorization in writing or by a similarly authenticated method, and a copy for the patient. Regulation E, at 12 CFR 1005.10(b), applies that to preauthorized electronic fund transfers from a consumer's account, which is what a monthly membership debit is.

For an online signup, our reading is that "similarly authenticated" means the method has to tie the authorization to the patient, and the copy can be the confirmation email. What we would put in the authorization, so a patient reading it later knows exactly what they agreed to:

  • Your company name as it will appear on the bank statement.
  • The amount, or how the amount is set if it can change.
  • How often the debit runs, and when it starts.
  • Which account, by its last four digits.
  • How to cancel, and how much notice cancellation needs.

Nacha's Operating Rules add their own authorization requirements for each entry type, so confirm your wording with your processor and counsel; this post isn't legal advice. And make sure your membership cancellation actually stops the debits. A cancelled membership that keeps debiting can produce unauthorized returns, and the subscription rules that apply on the card side, from Visa's checkout disclosure to state auto-renewal laws, are in subscription billing for telehealth.

Nacha's rules for online-authorized debits

Two sets apply to a telehealth company debiting patients from an online signup.

Account validation. Since March 2021, an originator's "commercially reasonable fraudulent transaction detection system" for WEB debits has had to include account validation the first time an account number is used, and again when it changes. Validation can run through a validation service, micro-entries or another method your processor supports. The point is to confirm the account exists and is open before you debit it.

Fraud monitoring, from 2026. Nacha's fraud-monitoring rules came in two phases:

PhaseEffectiveWho it covers
Phase 1March 20, 2026All ODFIs, plus non-consumer originators, third-party service providers and third-party senders with at least 6 million ACH originations in 2023
Phase 2June 19, 2026 (in practice Monday, June 22, 2026, since June 19 was a federal holiday)All remaining non-consumer originators, third-party service providers and third-party senders, regardless of volume

A telehealth company that debits patients through a processor is a non-consumer originator, so Phase 2 covers it if Phase 1 didn't already. The rule requires risk-based processes to identify entries authorized under false pretenses, meaning payments someone was tricked into authorizing, and a review of those processes at least once a year.

Return rates that put an ACH program under review

Nacha sets three thresholds, and the unauthorized one is the tightest.

Return categoryThresholdWhat it covers, in plain terms
Unauthorized0.5%Debits the account holder says they didn't authorize, including returns coded R05, R07, R10, R11, R29 and R51
Administrative3.0%Bad account data: closed accounts, accounts that can't be found, invalid account numbers (R02, R03, R04)
Overall15%All returns, including insufficient funds

Three of the unauthorized codes worth knowing by name:

  • R10. A consumer tells their bank the debit wasn't authorized, or that they don't recognize the company. An unfamiliar company name on the statement can produce R10s on its own.
  • R29. A business account holder tells its bank the debit wasn't authorized. In telehealth this can happen when a patient pays from a business account.
  • R05. A consumer account was debited using an entry type meant for business accounts.

Unauthorized returns can arrive well after the debit settles, so a clean first week says little. Watch the rate by month, and treat an unauthorized return as the end of that authorization until the patient gives you a new one.

What the patient sees on their bank statement

Your company name and a short entry description, on a statement other people in the household may read. The rule that applies to card descriptors applies here too: use the brand the patient signed up under, so the debit is recognizable, and keep conditions and drug names out of the description. A debit the patient can't place invites an unauthorized return, and a description that names a treatment puts patient information somewhere your HIPAA program doesn't reach.

Put the statement name in the authorization text and in the confirmation email, so the patient has seen it before the first debit posts. If the name changes, tell patients before the next debit, not after it.

When ACH fits a telehealth membership, and when it doesn't

It fits where the patient relationship is established and the timing of delivery leaves room for a debit to clear. It fits less well where you ship medication to a first-time patient the day they sign up.

SituationACH fitWhy
Larger memberships or quarterly and annual prepaymentsGoodLarger amounts, fewer debits, and patients who may prefer to pay from a bank account
Established patients on a monthly planGoodThe authorization and the account have a track record
Patients without a usable cardGoodA payment option you would otherwise not have
First-time patients with medication shipped at signupWeakThe shipment goes out before you know whether the debit will be returned

Timing is the part to plan around. Standard ACH settles in a business day or more, and Same Day ACH settles the same day, with a per-payment limit of $1 million since March 2022. Neither tells you a debit won't come back. Settlement and finality are different things for bank debits, and a program that ships on settlement carries the return risk.

Setting up recurring ACH for a membership

  1. Capture the authorization with the terms above, and email the patient a copy.
  2. Validate the account on first use, and again if the patient changes it.
  3. Debit on the stated schedule, and tell patients before an amount changes.
  4. Track returns by category each month, and stop debiting on any unauthorized return.
  5. Run your false-pretenses monitoring and review it at least annually.
  6. Make sure cancelling a membership stops the next debit.

Patients who pay by card go through a different set of rules for stored credentials and retries, covered in recurring billing for subscription telehealth. VyaPay's VyaLynk gateway runs ACH and eCheck alongside card-present and card-not-present payments through one direct API, so both rails can live in one billing setup. Talk to VyaPay about adding bank payments.

Frequently asked questions

How quickly does an ACH debit settle?

Settlement takes a business day or more on standard ACH, or the same day with Same Day ACH (up to $1 million per payment). Settling doesn't make it final: the debit can still be returned afterwards.

Does an online checkbox count as written authorization?

Regulation E accepts authorization by a similarly authenticated method, so an online authorization can qualify if the method ties it to the patient and the patient gets a copy. Confirm your flow against Nacha's rules with your processor.

What's the difference between eCheck and ACH?

eCheck is a name for one use of ACH: a debit the account holder authorizes online or by phone by giving their account details. It runs on the same network as any other ACH debit.

What happens when a patient's debit comes back unauthorized?

It counts toward Nacha's 0.5% unauthorized return threshold. Stop debiting that account and get a new authorization before you try again.

Sources

Talk to the team that underwrites you

Tell us what you prescribe or sell, how you bill and who your pharmacy partners are. You'll be talking to the people who run VyaPay's processor and make its risk decisions.

or call 833-4-VYAPAY

Let’s meet up!

Tell us about your business and someone from our team will reach out.