Telehealth payments

Subscription Billing for Telehealth: Card-Network Rules, State Auto-Renewal Laws and the FTC in 2026

The FTC's click-to-cancel rule is gone for now, but ROSCA, Visa's checkout rules and state auto-renewal laws still apply. Where each stands as of November 2026, and a checklist built from them.

By VyaPayPublished 7 min read

Three sets of rules apply to a telehealth subscription. Visa requires restricted cancellation or refund terms to be disclosed in checkout with an acknowledgement, and gives cardholders a dispute for cancelled recurring charges. The FTC's 2024 click-to-cancel amendments were vacated in July 2025, but ROSCA still governs online negative-option sales. And about 30 states have auto-renewal laws, by reported counts, with California's reported as amended effective July 1, 2025.

A negative option is a sales term under which the customer's silence, or failure to cancel, is taken as agreement to be charged again. A telehealth membership that renews every month until the patient cancels is one. In federal law, ROSCA governs online negative-option sales while the FTC rewrites its Negative Option Rule, and about 30 states, by reported counts, have automatic-renewal laws.

What do card networks require of a telehealth subscription?

Disclosure before the patient pays, and a dispute right afterwards. Section 5.4.2.5 of the Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (24 October 2026) says a merchant that restricts returns or cancellation must disclose its policy. For e-commerce, that disclosure belongs in the checkout sequence before final checkout, with a click-to-accept button, a checkbox or another acknowledgement. A link is acceptable only as part of that acknowledgement, not as a footer the patient never opens.

After the sale, Visa's dispute rules include condition 13.2, Cancelled Recurring Transaction (§11.11.3). It is the cardholder's route when they say they cancelled and were billed anyway. Our reading is that this is where a confusing subscription design costs you, one dispute at a time, which is why the evidence you keep at signup and cancellation matters as much as the checkout itself.

Where the FTC's click-to-cancel rule stands in November 2026

Back where it started, with a new rulemaking under way. The sequence:

  • 2024: the FTC adopts "click-to-cancel" amendments to its Negative Option Rule.
  • July 2025: the Eighth Circuit vacates the amendments on procedural grounds.
  • February 2026: the FTC restores the pre-2024 rule text.
  • March 2026: the FTC issues an advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPRM) on a new negative-option rule.
  • As of November 2026: no new rule, as far as our research shows.

What didn't change is ROSCA, the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act. It is a statute, so a court decision on the FTC's rule amendments didn't touch it, and it still applies to online negative-option sales. The FTC also has its general authority under the FTC Act. The click-to-cancel rule is gone for now; the FTC's interest in memberships that are hard to cancel is not, as the NextMed case below shows.

Which state auto-renewal laws matter?

The ones in the states where your patients live. About 30 states have automatic-renewal laws, according to published counts, and California's, the one people search for by name, was amended effective July 1, 2025, according to legal summaries of the change. We don't summarize each state's requirements here; they are separate laws written at different times, and an older checklist may predate California's amendments.

Telehealth has one advantage on this point. Your clinicians are licensed state by state, so you already keep a list of the states you serve, and that list doubles as the list of states whose auto-renewal laws your counsel should check. This post is general information, not legal advice.

What the FTC alleged in the NextMed case

That a GLP-1 membership hid its real cost and its real term. In FTC v. NextMed (July 2025), the FTC alleged that a telehealth weight-loss membership priced at about $138 or $188 a month didn't adequately disclose that medication, lab work and consults cost extra. It alleged that members were locked into one-year terms billed every 28 days, and that cancelling was hard. It also alleged unsupported average weight-loss claims and fake testimonials and before-and-after photos. NextMed settled for $150,000, and the FTC later approved the final order.

Two details make the case useful for subscription design. First, the counts were brought under sections 5 and 12 of the FTC Act, not ROSCA and not the click-to-cancel amendments, so the vacated rule wasn't needed to bring it. Second, the billing allegations were about clarity rather than the billing model itself: what the price covered, how often it was charged, and how long the patient was committed.

A subscription checkout checklist for telehealth

Show the patient what they are agreeing to, record that they agreed, and make leaving as easy as joining. Each item below ties to a rule or to an allegation above:

What to show or doWhy
The price per billing period, next to the payment buttonThe first thing a patient needs to know before agreeing to a renewal
What the price excludes: medication, labs, extra consultsThe FTC's NextMed complaint alleged these costs weren't adequately disclosed
The billing interval in plain words, such as "every 28 days" if that is what it isNextMed's 28-day billing on one-year terms was part of the FTC's allegations
Any minimum term or commitment, before paymentSame allegations; a term the patient didn't see invites a 13.2 dispute
Cancellation and refund restrictions, with a checkbox or click-to-acceptVisa §5.4.2.5
A stored consent record: terms version, timestamp, what was displayedYour evidence if a 13.2 dispute arrives
A reminder before renewals, especially long intervals or price changesFewer surprised patients; check state laws for notice requirements
Online cancellation in the same place the patient signed upThe FTC alleged NextMed made cancelling hard
A cancellation confirmation by email, with the dateEvidence for the patient and for you

How subscription design shows up in disputes and underwriting

As 13.2 disputes first, then as questions in your next review. A patient who can't find the cancel button may file a dispute instead, and each one counts against your ratio. So if your application includes recurring billing, expect the underwriter to read your checkout screen by screen.

The mechanics behind the checkout matter too. How you store the card, what consent you record and how you retry a failed renewal within Visa's limits are in recurring billing for subscription telehealth. What to send when a cancelled-recurring dispute arrives is in telehealth chargebacks, and GLP-1 programs, where memberships and prepaid plans meet, are covered in payment processing for GLP-1 telehealth.

VyaPay supports saved cards and recurring billing on its own processor, and the in-house team that reviews your checkout is the one that keeps the account live afterwards. If you're designing a membership and want it read before launch, talk to VyaPay.

Frequently asked questions

Is the FTC click-to-cancel rule in effect?

Not as of November 2026. The 2024 amendments were vacated by the Eighth Circuit in July 2025, the FTC put the earlier rule text back in February 2026, and it opened a new rulemaking in March 2026. ROSCA still applies to online negative-option sales.

Does California's auto-renewal law apply to telehealth memberships?

It isn't written for telehealth in particular. Whether it reaches your plan depends on the plan's terms and where your patients are, which is a question for counsel, and any checklist written before the amendments that legal summaries date to July 1, 2025 may be out of date.

Can I bill every 28 days instead of monthly?

The FTC's NextMed complaint alleged that members didn't understand they were billed every 28 days on one-year terms. Whatever interval you choose, say it in exactly those words before the patient pays and again in renewal reminders.

Do I have to refund a patient who cancels mid-cycle?

Visa's rules don't set your refund policy. They require you to disclose any restriction in checkout and get an acknowledgement. Your terms and the state laws that apply to you decide the rest.

Sources

Talk to the team that underwrites you

Tell us what you prescribe or sell, how you bill and who your pharmacy partners are. You'll be talking to the people who run VyaPay's processor and make its risk decisions.

or call 833-4-VYAPAY

Let’s meet up!

Tell us about your business and someone from our team will reach out.