Telehealth Chargebacks: The Dispute Types Clinics Face and How to Answer Each
Telehealth disputes come in a handful of shapes. Each one has its own evidence, and none of them needs the patient's chart.
Telehealth disputes fall under a handful of Visa conditions: 13.1 when medication or a visit didn't arrive, 13.2 when a patient says they cancelled, 13.3 when the result wasn't what they expected, 10.4 when someone says the charge wasn't theirs, and credit-not-processed claims over promised refunds. Each needs different evidence, and none needs the chart. Prevention comes down to clear billing, a recognizable descriptor and answering issuer inquiries early.
Friendly fraud is the industry's name for a dispute filed on a purchase the cardholder, or someone in their household, actually made or authorized, presented to the issuer as fraud or as something not received. In telehealth it can come from a forgotten renewal, an unrecognized descriptor or a family member using a saved card.
Which dispute types do telehealth merchants face?
These five come up, each tied to a point in the patient journey where something went wrong or looked wrong. Visa's condition names are in the first column:
| Visa condition | What the patient tells the issuer | Telehealth trigger | Evidence that answers it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10.4 Other Fraud – Card-Absent | "I didn't make this charge" | A family member used a saved card; a renewal the cardholder doesn't recognize | Login and device history, identity match at intake, delivery to the cardholder's address, earlier undisputed charges |
| 13.1 Merchandise/Services Not Received | "I never got it" | A pharmacy or shipping delay; a visit that didn't happen | Tracking and delivery confirmation; a visit log with date, time, clinician and duration |
| 13.2 Cancelled Recurring Transaction | "I cancelled" | A cancellation path that is hard to find; a renewal after a forgotten intro period | Signup consent record, cancellation log, renewal notices sent |
| 13.3 Not as Described or Defective | "It wasn't what was promised" | Expectations set by marketing; a product that differed from the page | Terms accepted, the product page as it read at purchase, what was delivered |
| Credit not processed (a separate Visa condition) | "They promised a refund" | Support promised a refund and none was issued | Refund records, or the policy the patient accepted and why it doesn't apply |
How to answer each one
With evidence about the transaction, matched to what the patient claimed. A response that argues the wrong point can lose even when the merchant is right.
Fraud claims from inside the household (10.4)
Show that the person who paid is the person who used the service, or lives where it was delivered. Login history from the same device, an intake identity check that matches the cardholder, shipping to the billing address, and months of earlier charges on the same card that weren't disputed all point the same way. If the user was a family member, your account records may show it; you don't need to describe their care to make the point.
Medication or visits not received (13.1)
For shipped medication, carrier tracking with a delivery scan to the address on the order. For a visit, a log showing the appointment, the clinician, the start time and the duration. If the pharmacy partner ships, agree in advance how fast it will send you tracking for a disputed order, because the response window doesn't wait for it.
Cancelled recurring (13.2)
The consent record from signup, the date of any cancellation request, the renewal notices you sent, and your cancellation terms as accepted at checkout. If the patient did cancel and you billed anyway, accept the dispute rather than fight it. How to design the checkout so fewer of these arrive is covered in subscription billing rules for telehealth.
Not as described (13.3)
The page the patient saw, the terms they accepted and proof that what they bought was delivered. Marketing is the weak point here. The FTC alleged in its NextMed case, settled in July 2025, that the company lacked substantiation for its average weight-loss claims; our reading is that a results claim you can't back up is a 13.3 dispute waiting to happen, as well as a regulatory problem.
Credit not processed
Refund records with dates, or the refund policy the patient accepted and the reason it doesn't cover their request. The cheapest fix is upstream: if support promises a refund, the refund should go out the same day.
How much patient information belongs in dispute evidence?
Enough to prove the transaction, not the treatment. Dispute evidence goes to the card issuer and can reach the cardholder, and Section 1179 of HIPAA, which keeps HIPAA off a financial institution's payment activities, doesn't take your own systems out of HIPAA if you're a covered entity. What your team pulls from the clinical record into a dispute response is still your decision and your exposure.
- Include: order and visit IDs, dates and times, the clinician's name, delivery records, the terms and consent record, login and device history.
- Leave out: diagnoses, intake answers, clinical notes, and medication names wherever a plan label such as "monthly membership" proves the point.
Your privacy counsel should sign off on the template once, so agents aren't deciding case by case. This is general information, not legal advice.
Stopping disputes before they become chargebacks
The cheapest work happens before the patient calls their bank: they should recognize the charge, be able to cancel without a fight, and get a refund when they're owed one. Specifically:
- A descriptor patients recognize. Visa's §1.5.1.12 requires the name you primarily use with customers, shown on your site and used consistently across authorization, clearing and dispute records. "I don't recognize this" can be the start of a fraud claim, so getting this right is covered in detail in billing descriptors for telehealth.
- Renewal notices before each charge on long intervals and after any price change.
- Refunds before disputes. A refund costs the sale. A chargeback costs the sale, a fee and a mark against your ratio.
- Fast answers to issuer inquiries. When an issuer asks about a transaction before a dispute is filed, order data sent back quickly can settle the question.
That last point is what VyaPay's VyaShield is built for: automated dispute responses and purchase-inquiry data sharing, so more disputes stop before they become chargebacks. If your dispute count is climbing, talk to VyaPay about what your data shows.
Why your dispute ratio follows you
Because Visa, your acquirer and the next acquirer all read it. Acquirers and chargeback vendors report that Visa's VAMP "excessive" threshold for merchants fell from 2.2% to 1.5% on April 1, 2026 in the US, with a minimum of 1,500 fraud reports plus disputes a month. In those reports the ratio is TC40 fraud reports plus TC15 disputes, divided by settled card-not-present transactions, and the fee is $8 per fraud report or dispute, charged through the acquirer. Visa's own rules let it terminate a merchant for VAMP non-compliance (§1.9.1.4).
If you sell prescriptions and your account is treated as high-integrity risk, there's more. Visa's rules make the acquirer track disputes daily for high-integrity risk merchants (§10.4.5.2), and Visa may disqualify one that reaches a critical level of disputes (§10.4.5.4). A terminated merchant can be added to Mastercard's MATCH list, where, as acquirers and vendors describe it, listings stay for five years. How dispute history fits into the wider question of risk classification is covered in is telehealth a high-risk business.
Frequently asked questions
Can I win a friendly fraud chargeback?
You can, when the evidence shows the cardholder or their household used the service. Issuers decide on what you send, and login history, delivery records and a clear consent record are what make the case. We don't quote win rates.
Should I refund instead of fighting a dispute?
Before a dispute is filed, a refund is cheaper when the patient has a point. Once a dispute is filed, don't refund the same charge as well, or you risk paying it back twice.
What counts toward Visa's VAMP ratio?
As vendors describe it, the fraud reports (TC40) and disputes (TC15) on your account, measured against your settled card-not-present transactions. We're relying on vendor reports for the formula and the thresholds, so confirm both with your acquirer.
Do I have to send medical records to win a telehealth dispute?
In our view, no. Card disputes turn on authorization, delivery and the terms the patient accepted, and all of that can be shown without clinical detail.
Sources
- Visa, Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules, 24 October 2026 (sections 1.5.1.12, 1.9.1.4, 10.4.5.2, 10.4.5.4, 11.11.3)
- Legal Information Institute, 42 U.S.C. 1320d-8 (HIPAA Section 1179)
- Acquirer and chargeback-vendor summaries of Visa's VAMP thresholds, effective April 1, 2026
- Federal Trade Commission, FTC v. NextMed, complaint and settlement, July 2025
